First-party and third-party claims after a crash
Which claim runs on your own policy and which runs on someone else's, what each one owes you and asks of you, and why the order you open them in matters.
A first-party claim is made on your own policy, such as collision, PIP, medical payments, or uninsured motorist coverage. A third-party claim is made against someone else's policy, usually the at-fault driver's liability coverage. First-party claims run under your contract, with a duty of good faith owed to you, built-in dispute tools, and duties you must meet. Third-party claims run on proof of fault and harm, with no contract between you and the insurer. One crash often opens both, and the order you open them, the releases you sign, and the different deadlines on each side decide how fast you are paid and how much.
Collision Bureau is not a law firm and this is not legal or medical advice. It is general information about what happens after a crash. For advice on your situation, talk to an attorney licensed in your state or a treating medical provider.
What first-party and third-party mean
Every insurance claim after a crash is one of two kinds, and the kind decides almost everything about how it runs. A first-party claim is a claim you make against your own insurance policy. A third-party claim is a claim you make against someone else's policy, usually the at-fault driver's.
The names come from the contract. An insurance policy is an agreement between two parties: the insurance company and the person who bought the policy. When the person who bought the policy makes a claim under it, that is a claim between the first and second parties to the contract. The insured is the first party. When someone outside the contract makes a claim, usually because the insured hurt them or damaged their property, that person is a third party. They are not part of the contract, but the contract exists in part to pay them.
The same crash usually produces both kinds. Your collision coverage paying to fix your car is a first-party claim. The other driver's liability insurance paying for your car instead is a third-party claim. Your personal injury protection paying your medical bills is a first-party claim. The other driver's bodily injury liability paying for your injury is a third-party claim. Your uninsured motorist coverage paying when the other driver had no insurance is a first-party claim, even though it pays for harm the other driver caused.
This is not just vocabulary. The two kinds of claim give the claimant different rights, different duties, different deadlines, and different ways to resolve a disagreement. The adjuster handling each one works for a company with a different relationship to the claimant. A person who understands which kind of claim they are in can predict how it will go. A person who does not will keep being surprised.
Here is the rule this whole guide builds on. On a first-party claim, you are the insurer's customer, the policy is your contract, and the insurer owes you duties under it. On a third-party claim, you are a stranger to the contract, the insurer's customer is the person who hurt you, and your rights come mostly from the law of negligence, not from the policy.
The contract and the duty
Insurance law treats the insurer's relationship with its own policyholder as special. In nearly every state, an insurer owes its insured a duty of good faith and fair dealing. That duty is implied into the contract. It means the insurer must investigate claims reasonably, evaluate them fairly, pay what is owed promptly, and not put its own interests ahead of the insured's in ways the policy does not allow.
That duty runs to the policyholder and to others the policy covers, such as family members in the household or people driving the car with permission. It does not generally run to a stranger making a claim against the policyholder. The at-fault driver's insurer owes its duties to the at-fault driver. Its job, on a third-party claim, is to protect its insured from liability and to resolve the claim for no more than it is worth. That is not bad faith. It is the structure.
The difference shows up in the adjuster's behavior. A first-party adjuster is handling a claim from a customer, under a contract that spells out what is covered, and under a duty that can be enforced if the insurer acts unreasonably. A third-party adjuster is handling a claim from someone the company has no contract with, evaluating whether its own customer is legally responsible, and how much that responsibility is worth. Both are doing their jobs. They are not the same job. The guide on why the adjuster is not your adjuster goes into the adjuster's side.
States also regulate how insurers handle claims through unfair claims settlement practices laws. Most states have one, often based on a model law developed by the National Association of Insurance Commissioners. These laws list practices insurers must avoid, such as misrepresenting policy terms, failing to acknowledge claims promptly, or failing to make a reasonable investigation. Many of these protections apply to both first-party and third-party claimants, but in most states they are enforced by the state insurance department, not by a private lawsuit.
The test is to ask, for every claim, who the adjuster's customer is. If it is you, the policy and the duty of good faith are your strongest tools. If it is the other driver, your strongest tools are the evidence of fault and the evidence of harm.
The first-party coverages on an auto policy
An auto policy is really a bundle of separate coverages, each with its own limits, deductibles, and rules. Several of them pay the policyholder directly, which makes any claim under them a first-party claim. The declarations page lists which ones a policy has. The guide to reading your declarations page walks through it line by line.
Collision coverage pays to repair or replace the policyholder's vehicle after a crash, regardless of who caused it, minus a deductible. It is optional in most states unless a lender or lease requires it. Comprehensive coverage pays for damage from causes other than a collision, such as theft, fire, hail, flooding, or an animal strike, also minus a deductible.
Personal injury protection, often called PIP, pays medical bills and often a share of lost wages and other losses for the policyholder and others covered by the policy, regardless of fault. It is required in no-fault states and available in some other states. Medical payments coverage, often called MedPay, pays medical bills for the policyholder and passengers regardless of fault, usually with lower limits and fewer categories than PIP. The guides to PIP and MedPay cover the details.
Uninsured motorist coverage pays for the policyholder's injuries, and in some states property damage, when the at-fault driver has no insurance or cannot be identified, as in many hit-and-run crashes. Underinsured motorist coverage pays when the at-fault driver's insurance is not enough to cover the policyholder's injuries. Both are first-party claims, even though they pay for harm the other driver caused. The guide to uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage covers them in depth.
Smaller coverages round out the policy. Rental reimbursement pays for a rental car while the policyholder's car is being repaired after a covered claim, up to daily and total caps. Towing and roadside coverage pays for towing and certain roadside services. Some policies include coverages for custom equipment, glass, or other specific items.
The rule is that each of these is a separate promise in the same contract. A claim under one does not automatically trigger another. Each has to be claimed, and each has its own limit and its own conditions.
It is worth reading the declarations page before the first call to any insurer. People are often surprised in both directions: by coverage they did not know they had, such as medical payments or rental reimbursement, and by coverage they assumed they had but declined at purchase to lower the premium. Knowing what is on the page avoids promises from an adjuster that the policy cannot keep, and avoids leaving a coverage unclaimed.
The third-party coverages
The coverages that pay other people are the liability coverages. Almost every state requires drivers to carry them, at least at a minimum level, because they exist to make sure people hurt by a driver can be paid.
Bodily injury liability pays for injuries the policyholder causes to other people: other drivers, passengers in any vehicle, pedestrians, cyclists. It is written with two limits in most states, a per-person limit and a per-accident limit. The per-person limit is the most the policy will pay for any one injured person. The per-accident limit is the most it will pay for everyone injured in the same crash. The guides to liability limits and policy limits explain how those numbers shape a claim.
Property damage liability pays for damage the policyholder causes to other people's property, most often their vehicles, but also fences, buildings, utility poles, and anything else in the way. It has its own limit.
Liability coverage also includes a promise that does not show up as a dollar figure: the duty to defend. If the policyholder is sued for a covered crash, the insurer generally must provide and pay for a lawyer to defend them, in addition to paying any settlement or judgment up to the limits. That duty to defend, and the insurer's control over settlement decisions, is part of why the at-fault driver's insurer is so central to a third-party claim.
From the claimant's side, these coverages are what a third-party claim draws on. The claimant does not have a contract with the insurer, but the insurer has promised its policyholder that it will pay valid claims against them up to the limits. In most cases that promise is how the claimant actually gets paid, because the at-fault driver personally may have little ability to pay beyond the insurance.
The test is to find the at-fault driver's limits as early as possible. Some states require insurers to disclose limits on request, sometimes only after certain conditions are met, and some do not. The limits are often the single biggest factor in what a third-party injury claim can realistically recover.
Some drivers carry an umbrella policy, a separate policy that adds liability coverage above the auto policy's limits. Umbrella coverage usually applies only after the underlying auto limits are used up. It is less common, and people often do not mention it unless asked, but for a serious injury it can change the picture. The question of whether the at-fault driver has an umbrella policy, or any other liability coverage, is worth raising early.
How a first-party claim usually runs
A first-party claim has a familiar rhythm, because insurers handle thousands of them and most follow the same steps. Knowing the steps makes it easier to see when a claim is moving normally and when it has stalled.
It starts with the report. The policyholder calls the insurer, uses its app, or files online, and gives the basic facts: when and where the crash happened, who was involved, the other driver's information, and any injuries. The insurer opens a claim and assigns a claim number for each coverage that applies. Collision and medical payments may have separate numbers and separate adjusters.
Next comes the investigation and the inspection. For the vehicle, the insurer inspects the damage, either through a field appraiser, a photo estimate taken through an app, or an inspection at a shop. It writes an estimate of the repair cost or decides the car is a total loss. For injury coverages like PIP or medical payments, the insurer asks for medical records and bills and may ask for a statement. The guides to how a collision repair estimate works and how a total loss number gets decided explain the vehicle side.
Then payment. For a repair, the insurer pays the shop or the policyholder, minus the deductible. If the shop finds hidden damage once the car is taken apart, it submits a supplement, an additional estimate for the extra work, and the insurer reviews and usually pays it. The guide to the supplement explains how that works. For a total loss, the insurer offers the vehicle's actual cash value, minus the deductible, and pays the lender first if there is a loan. For medical coverages, the insurer pays providers or reimburses the policyholder as bills come in, up to the limit.
Last, subrogation, if someone else was at fault. The insurer pursues the at-fault party's insurer in the background, often long after the policyholder's car is back on the road.
The test of a first-party claim moving normally is that each step has a clear next action and a rough timeline. If the policyholder cannot get an answer about what happens next, or an inspection or payment has been pending well past what the adjuster said, a written request for status, citing the claim number, is the right next move.
How a third-party claim usually runs
A third-party claim has a different rhythm, because the first question is always whether the other insurer's customer is responsible. Until that question is answered, little else moves.
It starts with notice. The claimant reports the claim to the at-fault driver's insurer, using the policy information exchanged at the scene or found in the police report. The insurer opens a claim, assigns an adjuster, and contacts its own policyholder to get their account. If the policyholder does not report the crash, the insurer may wait to hear from them before moving forward.
Then the liability investigation. The adjuster reviews the police report, statements from both drivers and any witnesses, photos, and sometimes the vehicles themselves. The insurer then accepts liability, denies it, or accepts a share of it. That decision is what opens the way to payment. A claimant who cannot get a liability decision after a reasonable period should ask for it in writing.
Once liability is accepted, the property side usually moves fairly quickly: an inspection or estimate, payment for the repair or total loss, and rental or loss of use for a reasonable period. Diminished value, if available in the state, often requires a separate request with supporting documentation.
The injury side takes longer. The claimant treats, gathers records and bills, and usually waits until treatment reaches maximum medical improvement before sending a demand. The insurer evaluates the demand, makes an offer, and the two sides negotiate. A settlement is documented in a release, which ends the claim. If the two sides cannot agree, the claimant can file a lawsuit before the statute of limitations runs. The guides to the bodily injury claim and the demand letter cover the injury side in detail.
The test of a third-party claim moving normally is a liability decision in writing within a reasonable time. Everything else on the third-party side waits for it.
One crash, both kinds of claim
A single crash can open several claims at once, some first-party and some third-party, each with its own adjuster and claim number. Walking through a common example shows how they fit together.
Picture a driver stopped at a red light who is rear-ended. Their car is badly damaged and their neck is injured. They have collision coverage, medical payments coverage, and underinsured motorist coverage on their own policy. The other driver has the minimum liability limits required in their state.
On the property side, the injured driver can make a third-party property damage claim against the other driver's insurer. If fault is clear and the other insurer accepts liability quickly, that claim may pay for the repair, a rental, and possibly diminished value. Or the injured driver can make a first-party collision claim under their own policy, pay the deductible, get the repair started right away, and let their insurer recover from the other insurer later.
On the injury side, the injured driver's medical payments coverage may pay the first medical bills regardless of fault, as a first-party claim. Their health insurance may pay too. Later, they make a third-party bodily injury claim against the other driver's liability insurance. If the injury is worth more than the other driver's per-person limit, they may make a first-party underinsured motorist claim under their own policy for the difference, usually after getting their own insurer's consent to settle with the other driver.
That is at least four claims from one crash: third-party property damage, possibly first-party collision, first-party medical payments, third-party bodily injury, and possibly first-party underinsured motorist. Each one has its own rules. Each one is handled by an adjuster with a different relationship to the driver. And the order they are opened in matters, as the following sections explain.
The test is to list every claim the crash could produce before opening any of them. Property and injury, first-party and third-party, each with the policy it runs against. That list is the map for everything that follows.
How fault works differently on each side
Fault is the dividing line between the two kinds of claim. A third-party claim depends on it. A first-party claim mostly does not.
A third-party claim is a claim that the other driver was negligent and that their negligence caused the harm. The other driver's insurer will only pay if it accepts that its policyholder was legally responsible, or if it decides the risk of a lawsuit is worth settling. If the insurer disputes fault, the third-party claim stalls until the evidence changes the insurer's view or a court decides. The guide to how fault actually gets decided covers how that happens.
Shared fault also changes a third-party claim. Most states use some form of comparative negligence, which reduces the claimant's recovery by their own share of fault. Some states bar recovery if the claimant's fault reaches a certain threshold, commonly 50 or 51 percent. A small number of jurisdictions follow contributory negligence, which can bar recovery for any fault at all. The guides to comparative negligence and contributory negligence cover the rules.
A first-party claim generally does not depend on fault in the same way. Collision coverage pays to repair the policyholder's car whether they caused the crash or not. Personal injury protection and medical payments coverage pay regardless of fault. The policyholder's own fault can still matter in other ways, for example in whether the insurer later treats the crash as at-fault for premium purposes, or in limited exclusions, but it does not usually block the claim.
Uninsured and underinsured motorist claims are the exception that proves the rule. They are first-party claims, but they pay what the policyholder could have recovered from the at-fault driver. So the policyholder's own insurer looks at fault and damages much as the other driver's insurer would. That makes these claims feel adversarial even though they run against the policyholder's own policy.
The test is to sort claims by whether they need fault. Claims that do not, like collision, PIP and MedPay, can move quickly. Claims that do, like third-party liability and UM or UIM, move at the pace of the fault evidence.
The deductible and subrogation
When a first-party insurer pays for damage someone else caused, it does not simply absorb the cost. It has a right to recover what it paid from the at-fault party, usually from the at-fault party's insurer. That right is called subrogation, and it explains why using your own collision coverage first is often a reasonable choice even when the crash was clearly the other driver's fault.
Here is how it works. The policyholder makes a collision claim, pays the deductible, and their insurer pays for the repair. The policyholder's insurer then pursues the other driver's insurer for what it paid, plus the policyholder's deductible. If the subrogation succeeds, the policyholder usually gets their deductible back, in full or in part. The guides to subrogation and subrogation, the claim behind your claim go deeper.
Insurers often resolve subrogation claims between themselves without going to court. Many use inter-company arbitration, a system where member insurers submit disputed subrogation claims to arbitrators instead of suing each other. The policyholder usually does not participate directly. That means the deductible can take months to come back, and if the arbitrators assign some fault to the policyholder, only part of it may be returned.
Subrogation also affects the policyholder's own rights. Once the insurer has paid and holds the right to recover, the policyholder generally should not settle with or release the at-fault party in a way that wipes out the insurer's right. Most policies require the policyholder to cooperate with subrogation and to avoid doing anything that impairs it. A release signed with the other driver's insurer that includes the property damage the policyholder's own insurer already paid can create a conflict.
The same logic applies to medical coverages. If personal injury protection or medical payments coverage paid medical bills, the insurer may have a right to recover from the at-fault party, depending on state law and the policy. The guide to health insurance, Medicare and Medicaid liens covers repayment claims on the injury side.
The rule is to tell both insurers about each other. The first-party insurer needs to know the other driver's information to pursue subrogation. The third-party insurer needs to know what the first-party insurer has paid so that it is not paid twice.
Which property claim to open first
For the vehicle, the choice is usually between the third-party claim against the other driver's property damage liability and the first-party claim under the policyholder's own collision coverage. When both are available, each has advantages.
The third-party claim, when liability is clear and accepted, avoids the deductible entirely. It may also pay categories the first-party claim does not, such as diminished value in states that allow it and loss of use or a rental for a reasonable repair period. The guides to loss of use and diminished value cover those categories.
The first-party claim is often faster, because the policyholder's insurer does not have to decide fault before paying. It is governed by the policyholder's own contract, so the duty of good faith applies, and disputes about value can go to the policy's appraisal clause. It is also the only option when the other driver is uninsured for property damage, has denied liability, or simply has not responded.
Many people start with the third-party claim and switch to their own collision coverage if the other insurer delays or disputes fault. That is a common and reasonable pattern. What matters is not losing time while waiting. A car sitting at a shop or a tow yard accrues storage fees, and rental coverage under either claim may have limits. The guide to storage fees explains why delay costs money.
Rental is often the deciding factor in practice. The other driver's insurer may pay for a rental during a reasonable repair period if it accepts liability. The policyholder's own rental reimbursement coverage pays only if they bought it, and only up to its daily and total caps. The guide to the two caps in your rental coverage explains those limits.
The test is three questions. Has the other driver's insurer accepted liability in writing? Will it pay for a rental now? Is the car accruing storage or sitting unrepaired while the answer is pending? If the answers are no, no, and yes, the policyholder's own collision coverage is often the faster path.
Which injury coverage pays first
Medical bills start arriving within days of a crash, long before a third-party injury claim can be resolved. Something has to pay them in the meantime, and the order depends heavily on the state and on which coverages the injured person has.
In no-fault states, personal injury protection is typically the primary source of payment for medical bills and some lost wages, regardless of fault. The injured person claims PIP under their own policy, or in some situations under the policy covering the vehicle they were in. The right to bring a third-party bodily injury claim against the at-fault driver is limited until the injury meets a threshold set by state law, either a dollar amount of medical expenses or a level of seriousness defined in the statute. The guides to no-fault states and tort states explain the difference.
In fault-based states, the third-party claim against the at-fault driver is available from the start, but it does not pay as bills arrive. Medical payments coverage, if the injured person has it, can pay early bills regardless of fault. Health insurance usually pays as well, subject to its own repayment rights later. Some fault-based states also offer optional personal injury protection.
The order matters for two reasons. It decides who has to wait and who pays first, and it decides who will have a repayment claim against the eventual settlement. A health plan that paid bills that PIP should have paid may later ask for repayment, and the two payers may disagree about which one was responsible. Some states let the policyholder choose whether health insurance or PIP is primary, often through an election on the policy that lowers the PIP premium.
The third-party bodily injury claim usually comes later, after treatment has progressed far enough to understand the injury. If the at-fault driver's liability limits are too low to cover the full harm, the injured person's own underinsured motorist coverage may then add to what the liability policy paid.
The test is to identify, in the first week, every coverage that could pay medical bills: PIP, MedPay, health insurance, and the eventual third-party claim. Then confirm with each one, in writing, which pays first under the state's rules and the policy's terms.
What your own policy requires of you
A first-party claim comes with obligations, because it runs under a contract that the policyholder signed. Most auto policies contain a section on duties after an accident or loss. Failing to meet those duties can give the insurer a reason to deny or limit the claim, depending on the state's law about how much the failure must have hurt the insurer.
Prompt notice is the first. Policies require the policyholder to report the crash promptly, sometimes within a specific number of days, and to give details such as the time, place, and people involved. Late notice is one of the most common reasons first-party claims run into trouble.
Cooperation is the second. The policyholder must cooperate with the insurer's investigation. That usually includes giving a statement, often recorded, providing documents, allowing inspection of the vehicle, and sometimes submitting to an examination under oath, a formal sworn interview the policy allows the insurer to require. The guides to the recorded statement and the examination under oath explain each.
Proof of loss is the third. For some claims, the insurer can require a sworn statement of the loss, with supporting documents, within a set period after it asks. For injury coverages like PIP and MedPay, the policy usually requires medical records and bills and may allow the insurer to require an independent medical examination by a doctor it chooses. The guide to the independent medical examination covers that process.
Mitigation is the fourth. The policyholder must take reasonable steps to protect the vehicle from further damage, such as not driving a car that is unsafe and not leaving it where storage fees pile up without reason.
Last, the policyholder generally must not settle with or release the at-fault party in a way that harms the insurer's subrogation rights, and for underinsured motorist claims must usually get the insurer's consent before accepting the at-fault driver's policy limits.
The test is to read the duties section of the policy before the first conversation with the adjuster. It is usually only a page or two, and it describes exactly what the insurer can ask for.
What you owe the other driver's insurer
On a third-party claim, the claimant has no contract with the insurer, so the duties are very different. In general, a person making a claim against someone else's insurance has no contractual obligation to cooperate with that insurer at all.
That does not mean the claimant can be paid without proving anything. The insurer will not pay unless it is satisfied its policyholder is responsible and the claimed harm is real. So in practice, the claimant provides what is needed to prove fault and damages: photos, the police report, repair estimates, medical records, bills, proof of lost wages. The difference is that the claimant decides what to provide and when, as part of building the claim, rather than under a duty in a contract.
The recorded statement is the clearest example. The other driver's insurer will often ask for a recorded statement early in the claim. In most situations there is no obligation to give one, and many people decline, or give a written account instead, or wait until they have talked to an attorney. A recorded statement given in the first days after a crash, before the injury is fully understood, can be used later to argue the injury was minor or that the claimant shares fault. The guide to the recorded statement covers the tradeoffs.
Medical authorizations are another. The other driver's insurer may ask the claimant to sign a broad authorization giving it access to all of their medical records. A claimant usually has no obligation to sign one, and a broad authorization can give the insurer access to years of unrelated history. Many claimants provide the relevant records themselves instead, or use a limited authorization tied to the crash-related treatment.
The rule is that on a third-party claim, the claimant controls the evidence. That control is useful, but it carries the burden too. If the claimant does not prove fault and damages, nobody else will.
Being polite and responsive still helps. A third-party adjuster who receives clear documents promptly can move the claim forward, and one who hears nothing may simply wait. Declining a recorded statement or a broad authorization does not mean refusing to communicate. It means choosing what to provide, in what form, and keeping a copy of everything sent. A short cover letter listing each document enclosed is enough.
Good faith, bad faith, and who can sue for it
When an insurer handles its own policyholder's claim unreasonably, the policyholder may have a claim for bad faith, in addition to the claim for the benefits themselves. What counts as bad faith, and what can be recovered, varies by state. In general it involves an insurer denying or delaying payment without a reasonable basis, failing to investigate properly, or misrepresenting the policy. The guide to bad faith covers the concept in more detail.
Bad faith claims belong mainly to first-party claimants. A policyholder suing their own insurer for unreasonably denying a collision claim, delaying PIP benefits without basis, or lowballing an underinsured motorist claim is the classic example. Some states allow damages beyond the policy benefits in those cases, including in some circumstances punitive damages. Some states have statutes that add interest, penalties, or attorney fees for unreasonable delay.
Third-party claimants are in a different position. In most states, a person injured by an at-fault driver cannot sue that driver's insurer directly for bad faith in handling the claim, because the insurer owes its duties to its own policyholder, not to the claimant. The claimant's remedy is to pursue the at-fault driver, and the insurer then defends and pays on the driver's behalf.
There are important variations. A few jurisdictions, most notably Louisiana and Wisconsin, have direct action statutes that allow an injured person to sue the at-fault party's liability insurer directly in some circumstances. And in many states, if an insurer unreasonably refuses to settle a third-party claim within its policy limits and a judgment above the limits results, the policyholder may have a bad faith claim against their own insurer for exposing them to that excess judgment. In some states that claim can be assigned to the injured person as part of a settlement. These rules vary considerably.
State unfair claims settlement practices laws apply to both first-party and third-party claims in many states, but they are usually enforced by the state insurance department through complaints and regulatory action, not through private lawsuits. A complaint to the department can still prompt a response from an insurer that has been unresponsive.
The test is to ask whose contract it is. Bad faith remedies follow the contract. A third-party claimant's strength comes mostly from the strength of the claim and the at-fault driver's exposure, not from a duty owed to the claimant directly.
Know which claim you are in before the first call.
One request reaches a participating attorney licensed in your state, plus the tow, repair and rental. It costs you nothing.
When you disagree on the value
The two kinds of claim also resolve disagreements differently. On a first-party claim, the policy usually contains a mechanism for disputes. On a third-party claim, the options are negotiation or a lawsuit.
For property damage on a first-party claim, most auto policies include an appraisal clause. If the policyholder and the insurer disagree on the amount of the loss, either can demand appraisal. Each side picks an appraiser, the two appraisers pick an umpire, and an agreement by any two of the three sets the amount. Appraisal resolves the value of the loss, not whether the loss is covered. The guide to the appraisal clause explains the process, and the guides on reading a total loss offer and the first offer versus an independent appraisal cover the vehicle value side.
For uninsured and underinsured motorist claims, many policies and some state laws provide for arbitration if the policyholder and the insurer disagree on fault or the amount of damages. Arbitration can be faster and less formal than a lawsuit, but the rules, whether it is binding, and whether it is mandatory or optional vary by policy and state. The guide to arbitration covers the basics.
For PIP and medical payments disputes, the policy and state law may provide specific procedures, and some no-fault states have their own arbitration systems for disputed benefits.
A third-party claim has no built-in dispute mechanism, because there is no contract between the claimant and the insurer. If the claimant and the at-fault driver's insurer cannot agree, the claimant's main option is to file a lawsuit against the at-fault driver before the statute of limitations runs out. Many lawsuits still settle, often after mediation, which is a structured negotiation with a neutral mediator. The guide to mediation explains how that usually goes.
The rule is that the first-party side has a door built into the contract, and the third-party side has the courthouse door. Knowing which door is available shapes how hard to push in negotiation and when to stop negotiating.
Diminished value and loss of use on each side
Some categories of loss are available on one kind of claim and not the other, and diminished value is the clearest example.
Diminished value is the loss in a vehicle's market value because it has been in a crash, even after a good repair. A buyer will usually pay less for a car with an accident history than for the same car without one. On a third-party claim, many states allow the claimant to recover diminished value from the at-fault driver as part of the property damage, because the at-fault driver's negligence caused that loss. How it is calculated and proven varies, and insurers often dispute it. The guides to diminished value and the diminished value claim people never make explain how claimants pursue it.
On a first-party collision claim, most auto policies do not cover diminished value. The policy promises to repair or replace the vehicle, not to compensate for lost market value. A notable exception is Georgia, where the state's highest court held in 2001, in State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Co. v. Mabry, that first-party diminished value claims could be required under the policy language at issue. Outside of situations like that, a claimant who wants diminished value usually pursues it on the third-party side.
Loss of use is similar. On a third-party claim, the claimant can usually recover for the loss of use of their vehicle during a reasonable repair period, often measured by the cost of a comparable rental, even sometimes if they did not rent one, depending on the state. The guides to loss of use and the money people never claim for loss of use explain how. On a first-party claim, rental is covered only through rental reimbursement coverage, if the policyholder bought it, and only up to its caps.
This is one of the reasons people who use their own collision coverage for speed often still make a third-party claim against the other driver for the items their own policy does not cover: the deductible, diminished value, and loss of use beyond what their rental coverage paid.
The test is to list every property loss, then mark which side can pay it. The repair can usually be paid by either. The deductible, diminished value, and full loss of use usually belong to the third-party side.
Rental cars on each side
Rental is one of the most immediate questions after a crash, and the answer depends on which claim is paying.
On a third-party claim, the at-fault driver's insurer is generally responsible for the claimant's loss of use during a reasonable repair period, and that often means paying for a comparable rental. The insurer may only agree to a rental after it accepts liability, which can take days or weeks. It may arrange the rental directly through a company it works with, and it may cap the daily rate at what it considers comparable. If the repair takes longer than the insurer thinks is reasonable, it may stop paying.
On a first-party claim, rental reimbursement coverage, if the policyholder bought it, pays for a rental while the car is being repaired after a covered claim. It almost always has two caps: a daily limit and a total limit per claim. Once either cap is reached, the policyholder pays the rest. The coverage generally does not depend on fault, so it can start right away, which is one of its main advantages.
When the car is a total loss, rental usually continues for a limited period after the insurer makes its total loss offer, not until the claimant has bought a replacement. The guides to how long you can keep the rental and how rental coverage works after a crash explain the timing.
A common pattern is to start a rental under the policyholder's own rental reimbursement coverage, then ask the at-fault driver's insurer to take over or reimburse once it accepts liability. Keeping every rental receipt and the dates the car was at the shop makes that reimbursement much easier.
The test is to ask both insurers on the first day: who will pay for a rental, starting when, at what daily rate, and for how long? The answers often decide which claim to open first.
The type of rental matters too. The other driver's insurer generally owes a vehicle comparable to the one that was damaged, not necessarily the cheapest car available. A family that drove a minivan may need something that seats the same number of people. Rental reimbursement coverage, on the other hand, is limited by its daily cap, so the vehicle the policyholder can get depends on what the cap buys in their area. Asking for a comparable vehicle in writing, with the reason, is often enough to settle the question.
Uninsured and underinsured claims: first-party, but adversarial
Uninsured and underinsured motorist claims sit in an unusual place. They are first-party claims, made under the policyholder's own policy. But they pay for harm another driver caused, and the amount the policyholder can recover depends on what they could have recovered from that driver. So the policyholder's own insurer steps into the other driver's shoes for purposes of evaluating fault and damages.
That makes these claims feel adversarial in a way other first-party claims do not. The policyholder's insurer may question fault, argue the injury was minor or pre-existing, request an independent medical examination, and negotiate the value as firmly as a third-party insurer would. At the same time, because it is the policyholder's own insurer, the duty of good faith still applies, and unreasonable handling can support a bad faith claim in many states.
Underinsured motorist claims have a specific sequence. Usually the injured person first pursues the at-fault driver's liability coverage. If that insurer offers its full per-person limit, the injured person typically must notify their own insurer and obtain its consent before accepting, or give the insurer the opportunity to substitute its own payment, depending on the state and the policy. Accepting the at-fault driver's limits and signing a release without that step can jeopardize the underinsured motorist claim.
How underinsured coverage calculates what it pays varies by state and policy. In some, it pays the difference between the injured person's total damages and the at-fault driver's limits. In others, it pays the difference between the injured person's own underinsured limit and the at-fault driver's limit. The difference can be large. The guide to uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage and the guide to what happens when the other driver has no insurance explain both versions.
The test is to treat an uninsured or underinsured motorist claim like a third-party injury claim in how it is built, with evidence of fault and damages, and like a first-party claim in its rights and duties, with notice, cooperation, consent to settle, and the duty of good faith.
The deadlines are different
Each kind of claim runs on its own clock, and missing one clock while watching another is one of the most damaging mistakes a claimant can make.
A third-party injury or property claim is governed by the statute of limitations for negligence claims in the state where the claim would be filed. If the claim is not resolved and a lawsuit is not filed before the deadline, the claim is usually lost. The deadline varies by state and by type of claim, and there are exceptions for minors, claims against government entities, and other situations. The guide to the statute of limitations after a car crash covers the deadlines state by state.
A first-party claim is governed by the policy and by contract law. Policies set notice deadlines for reporting the crash. They may set deadlines for submitting proof of loss. Many contain a suit limitation clause that sets a deadline for suing the insurer over the claim, which can be shorter than the general contract statute of limitations, subject to state rules about how short such clauses can be. Uninsured and underinsured motorist claims often have their own notice requirements, and some policies or states set specific deadlines for demanding arbitration.
Claims against government entities are an important exception on the third-party side. If the at-fault driver was driving a government vehicle, many states and the federal government require a formal notice of claim within a short period, sometimes months rather than years, before a lawsuit can be filed. Missing that notice can bar the claim even when the general statute of limitations has not run.
The deadlines also interact. An underinsured motorist claim may depend on resolving the liability claim first, but the underinsured motorist notice deadline may not wait for that. A first-party insurer's subrogation rights may depend on the policyholder not letting the third-party claim lapse.
The test is to write down every deadline at the start. The statute of limitations for the third-party claim. The policy's notice and proof-of-loss deadlines. Any suit limitation clause. Any government notice requirement. Any arbitration demand deadline. Then put the earliest one on the calendar first.
A practical habit helps here. Ask each insurer, in writing, whether there is any deadline the claimant needs to meet on that claim, and keep the answer. Adjusters are not the claimant's lawyers and an answer from one does not change the law or the policy, but the question often surfaces a requirement nobody mentioned, such as a proof of loss form with its own return date.
Does a claim raise your premium
Many people hesitate to use their own coverage because they worry about their premium. The worry is understandable, but the rules are more specific than most people expect.
Insurers set premiums based on risk, and an at-fault crash is a strong risk signal. When the policyholder caused the crash, a premium increase at renewal is common, whether or not a claim was filed on their own policy, because the at-fault crash itself is what the insurer is pricing. The guide to how premiums rise after a crash explains how surcharges usually work.
When the policyholder did not cause the crash, many states restrict or prohibit insurers from surcharging premiums or adding points for a not-at-fault accident. The specifics vary. Some states define what counts as not-at-fault. Some set limits on surcharges based on claims paid. Some allow insurers to consider the number of claims over time, regardless of fault, in certain ways. Insurers may also lose or change discounts tied to a claim-free history, which can raise the premium even when no surcharge applies.
Using collision coverage for a crash the other driver caused, and letting subrogation recover the cost, often does not result in an at-fault surcharge, because the insurer's own records will show the other driver was at fault. But it is a question worth asking the insurer directly, and the answer should be in writing.
Comprehensive claims, such as glass, theft, or weather damage, are treated differently by many insurers and states than collision claims. Personal injury protection and medical payments claims may be treated differently again.
The test is to ask the insurer before filing: is this crash being classified as at-fault or not-at-fault, and what effect will a claim under this coverage have on renewal? Then check the answer against the state insurance department's rules on surcharges, which most departments publish.
Premium worries should not decide whether to report the crash at all. Most policies require prompt notice of any crash that could lead to a claim, including one where the policyholder might be blamed. Not reporting it to save the premium can risk coverage if the other driver later makes a claim, because the insurer may argue it was not told in time. Reporting the crash and deciding which claims to make are separate steps.
Two adjusters, two files, one story
When a crash produces both first-party and third-party claims, the claimant will usually deal with at least two adjusters, sometimes at the same company, sometimes at different ones. Each adjuster keeps a separate file. Each file will be read later by others, possibly including a defense lawyer, an arbitrator, or a jury. The claimant's account of the crash and the injury needs to be the same in every one.
Inconsistency is the problem, not dishonesty. A claimant describes the crash one way to their own adjuster on the first day, while shaken up, and another way to the other driver's adjuster a week later, after thinking about it. The details differ: the speed, the lane, when they noticed the other car, whether their neck hurt right away. An adjuster looking for reasons to reduce a claim will find the difference and use it.
The simplest protection is writing. A short written summary of the crash, prepared early while memory is fresh, can be the reference for every later conversation. Requesting that communication happen in writing where possible, and following up phone calls with an email that restates what was said, builds a consistent record. The guide to the first call with the insurer covers how to approach those conversations.
Medical information needs the same care. What a claimant tells a doctor goes into the medical record. What they tell an adjuster goes into the claim notes. What they tell the independent medical examiner goes into that report. If the three accounts of when pain started or what activities are limited do not match, the inconsistency becomes an argument. The guide to why medical records decide injury claims explains why.
Documents flow between the files too. The first-party insurer may share information with the third-party insurer during subrogation. Repair estimates, photos, and the police report will appear in both files. Keeping track of what was sent to which insurer, and when, avoids confusion about what each one has.
The test is whether every account the claimant has given, in every file, could be laid side by side without contradiction. If the answer is yes, the claimant's credibility is an asset. If it is no, the claim is weaker than it needs to be.
Passengers, pedestrians and cyclists
The first-party and third-party labels work the same way for people who were not driving, but which policies count as first-party for them can be less obvious.
A passenger can usually make a third-party claim against the liability coverage of whichever driver caused the crash, including the driver of the car they were riding in. A passenger may also be covered by first-party coverages on the policy of the vehicle they were in, such as PIP or medical payments, because those coverages often extend to passengers. And a passenger may have first-party coverage under their own auto policy, or a policy covering their household, even though they were not in their own car. The guide to borrowed vehicle crashes explains how policies stack when the car belongs to someone else.
A pedestrian or cyclist hit by a car can make a third-party claim against the driver's liability coverage. Many people do not realize that their own auto policy, or a household member's, may also provide first-party coverage when they are hurt as a pedestrian or cyclist. Personal injury protection in many no-fault states covers the policyholder and household members when struck by a vehicle as pedestrians. Uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage often covers the policyholder as a pedestrian or cyclist hit by an uninsured or underinsured driver. The guides to pedestrian crashes and bicyclist crashes cover these situations.
Household definitions matter. Many policies extend coverage to relatives who live in the same household as the named policyholder. A college student living away from home, an adult child who moved back, or a relative staying temporarily may or may not count, depending on the policy's wording and state law.
The answers can be surprising. Someone without a car of their own may still be covered as a pedestrian or passenger under a parent's or spouse's policy. Someone with their own policy may have coverage under it and a household member's at the same time, with the policies deciding between themselves which pays first.
The test for anyone who was not driving their own car is to check three places for coverage: the policy on the vehicle involved, their own policy, and the policy of any relative they live with. Each one may contain first-party coverage that applies.
Commercial, rideshare and borrowed vehicles
When a vehicle involved in the crash belongs to a business, was being driven for a rideshare or delivery app, or was borrowed, the question of which policy pays and whose policy is first-party for whom gets more complex.
Commercial vehicles are usually insured under commercial auto policies that the business buys. If the commercial driver caused the crash, the claimant's third-party claim may run against the commercial policy, and possibly against the business itself if the driver was working. Commercial policies often have higher limits than personal policies, which can matter a great deal for serious injuries. The guide to commercial truck crashes covers the layers involved with large trucks.
Rideshare and delivery driving add another layer. Many states require transportation network companies to provide insurance that applies at different levels depending on the driver's app status: logged off, logged on and waiting for a request, or on the way to a pickup or carrying a passenger. The driver's own personal auto policy may exclude coverage while the app is on. A passenger in a rideshare vehicle usually has a third-party claim against the coverage that applies at the time of the crash. The guide to rideshare crashes explains the app-status tiers.
Borrowed vehicles raise the question of whether the owner's policy or the driver's policy pays first. In many states, insurance follows the car, meaning the owner's policy is primary for a permissive driver, and the driver's own policy may provide excess coverage. A passenger in a borrowed car may have first-party coverage under the owner's policy and their own.
Rental cars follow similar logic, with the rental company's coverage, the renter's own policy, and any coverage bought at the counter or through a credit card all potentially in play. The guide to rental car crashes sorts those out.
The test is to identify the owner of every vehicle involved and the purpose of every trip. Who owned the car? Was the driver working? Was an app on? Was the car borrowed or rented? Each answer can add a policy to the list.
When either claim is denied
Claims are denied on both sides for very different reasons, and the response depends on which side it is.
A first-party denial usually rests on the policy: the coverage did not apply, an exclusion applied, the policyholder failed a duty such as late notice or non-cooperation, or the insurer disputes that the loss happened as described. The policyholder is entitled to a written explanation that cites the policy language. Most states require insurers to give a reason for a denial. The first step is to ask for that explanation in writing, read the cited policy language, and respond with any information that addresses it.
If the response does not resolve it, the policyholder can use the policy's dispute mechanisms where they apply, file a complaint with the state insurance department, and in appropriate cases pursue a lawsuit for the benefits and possibly for bad faith. The guide to reservation of rights explains a related situation, where the insurer pays or investigates while reserving the right to deny later.
A third-party denial usually rests on liability: the insurer believes its policyholder was not at fault, or not mainly at fault, or that the claimed damages were not caused by the crash. The claimant does not have a contract to point to. The response is evidence. More photos, witness statements, the police report, video, expert opinions on how the crash happened, and medical records linking the injury to the crash. If the insurer still denies liability, the claimant's main remedy is a lawsuit against the at-fault driver before the deadline.
Denials on one side can push the claimant to the other. A third-party denial of property damage may lead to a first-party collision claim. A third-party denial of liability for injuries may lead to a first-party uninsured motorist claim in some situations, for example if the other driver's insurer denies coverage altogether, depending on the policy's definition of an uninsured vehicle.
The test is to read every denial for its reason. A coverage reason calls for the policy. A liability reason calls for evidence. A procedural reason, like a missed deadline or missing document, calls for prompt correction if it is still possible.
The mistakes that cost people the most
Most problems with first-party and third-party claims come from treating them as the same thing. A few mistakes come up again and again.
Waiting on the other driver's insurer while the car sits is the first. Storage fees accrue, rental limits get used, and the claimant goes without transportation, all while the third-party insurer investigates liability. Using the policyholder's own collision coverage, where available, can stop the clock on those costs.
Signing a release with the other driver's insurer without thinking about the first-party claims is the second. A release for property damage that sweeps in items the policyholder's own insurer already paid can interfere with subrogation. A release of the at-fault driver's bodily injury claim signed without the underinsured motorist carrier's consent can jeopardize that claim. The guide to release of liability explains what a release gives up.
Treating the other driver's insurer like your own is the third. Giving a recorded statement immediately, signing a broad medical authorization, or accepting the adjuster's description of what is covered, as though the adjuster owed the claimant the duties owed to a policyholder, can weaken a third-party claim.
Treating your own insurer like a stranger is the fourth. Refusing to cooperate, missing notice deadlines, or ignoring proof of loss requests on a first-party claim can give the insurer a contractual reason to deny it.
Missing the first-party coverage that exists is the fifth. Not checking for PIP or MedPay, not knowing about underinsured motorist coverage, or not realizing that a household member's policy may cover a pedestrian or passenger leaves money unclaimed.
Last, watching only one deadline. The statute of limitations gets the attention, while a policy notice deadline, a suit limitation clause, or a government notice requirement passes quietly.
And assuming the claims are finished when the car is fixed. The property claim usually closes long before the injury claim, the subrogation recovery, or the deductible refund. Treating the first closed claim as the end can leave the others unattended.
Have the claims looked at before the decisions get hard to undo.
One request, free to you. We route it to participating providers in your state and you decide what happens next.
The paper trail for each kind of claim
Both kinds of claim run on documents, but they need different documents, and keeping them separate makes everything easier.
For first-party claims, the policy itself is the most important document. The full policy, not just the declarations page, because the duties, exclusions, appraisal and arbitration clauses, and suit limitation clause are in the body of the policy. Then the claim number for each coverage, every letter from the insurer, every proof of loss submitted, every recorded statement or examination under oath transcript, payment records, and any denial or reservation of rights letter.
For third-party claims, the claimant's evidence file is the core. The police report, photos of the scene and vehicles, witness contact information, repair estimates and invoices, rental receipts, medical records and itemized bills, proof of lost wages, and every letter to and from the other driver's insurer. The guides to getting your crash report and reading a police crash report help with the first item.
Where the two overlap, keep track of what went where. Subrogation correspondence, the deductible paid and any amount returned, and any information exchanged between the two insurers should be in both files or cross-referenced.
And keep a single dated log of every call, with the name of the person, their company, the claim number, and what was said. That log is how inconsistencies are caught early and how disputes about what was promised get resolved later.
Photos deserve their own note. Pictures of the vehicles, the scene, and visible injuries taken in the first days are evidence that cannot be recreated later. Backing them up somewhere other than the phone that took them is a small step that avoids a large loss.
Handling it yourself or with an attorney
Many first-party and third-party claims are handled without an attorney, especially property-only claims where fault is clear and the vehicle damage is straightforward. Using collision coverage for speed and making a third-party claim for the deductible, rental, and diminished value is something many people manage on their own.
The case for an attorney grows with injuries, disputed fault, low liability limits, an underinsured motorist claim, a denial, or a deadline approaching. Underinsured motorist claims in particular involve consent-to-settle steps, offsets, and sometimes arbitration that are easy to get wrong. A first-party insurer handling an injury claim adversarially, a third-party insurer denying liability, or several policies stacking in a commercial, rideshare, or borrowed-vehicle crash are each situations where knowing the rules matters.
Injury claims also bring in repayment claims from health plans, Medicare, Medicaid, and auto medical coverages, which can significantly affect what the injured person keeps. Attorneys who handle these claims regularly deal with those repayment claims as part of the work.
A first conversation with an attorney licensed in your state is usually free, and many injury attorneys work on a contingency fee, which the guide to what a collision attorney costs explains. Collision Bureau routes requests to participating attorneys and does not rank or recommend any of them. The guides to settling yourself versus hiring an attorney and what happens when you talk to a collision attorney help with the decision.
The test is complexity. One property claim with clear fault is often realistic alone. Injuries, several policies, an underinsured motorist claim, a denial, or a close deadline are the signals to have the claims looked at before the decisions get hard to undo.
Whatever the decision, the claimant should keep control of the timeline. Opening the right claims early, meeting each policy duty, collecting the evidence, and writing down every deadline are steps that help whether or not an attorney is involved later, and they are much harder to do after the fact.
Questions people actually ask
01What is the difference between a first-party and a third-party claim?
A first-party claim is made under your own insurance policy. A third-party claim is made against someone else's policy, usually the at-fault driver's liability coverage. The rights, duties, deadlines and dispute options are different on each side.
02Should I file with my own insurance or the other driver's?
Often both. Your own collision coverage can be faster but has a deductible. The other driver's insurer may pay the deductible, rental and diminished value once it accepts liability. Many people start with one and use the other if it stalls.
03Is an uninsured motorist claim first-party or third-party?
First-party. It runs under your own policy, but your insurer evaluates fault and damages as the at-fault driver's insurer would. The duty of good faith still applies, and many policies require arbitration for disputes.
04Do I have to give a recorded statement to the other driver's insurer?
In most situations, no. You have no contract with that insurer. Your own insurer is different, because your policy usually requires cooperation, including statements. Many people give a written account or talk to an attorney first.
05Will I get my deductible back?
Often, if the other driver was at fault. Your insurer pursues the other driver's insurer through subrogation and usually returns your share of the deductible. It can take months, and only part may come back if fault is shared.
06Can I sue the other driver's insurance company for bad faith?
Generally not in most states, because the insurer owes its duties to its own policyholder. A few jurisdictions allow direct suits against liability insurers in some situations. Your own insurer can generally be sued for bad faith.
07Does a not-at-fault claim raise my premium?
Many states limit surcharges for not-at-fault crashes, but rules vary and claim-free discounts can still change. Ask your insurer how the crash is classified and check your state insurance department's rules.
08What is subrogation?
It is your insurer's right to recover what it paid from the at-fault party after paying your claim. It is why your insurer can pay for your repair and then collect from the other driver's insurer, often returning your deductible.
09Are the deadlines the same for both kinds of claim?
No. Third-party claims follow the state statute of limitations. First-party claims follow the policy's notice, proof-of-loss and suit limitation terms. Claims against government vehicles often need early notice. The earliest deadline matters most.
10Do I need an attorney for first-party and third-party claims?
Not always. Property-only claims with clear fault are often handled alone. Injuries, an underinsured motorist claim, disputed fault, a denial or a close deadline are strong reasons for a free consultation with an attorney licensed in your state.