How a bodily injury claim works after a car crash
The injury side of a crash claim, start to finish. Whose insurance pays, what the claim covers, how it gets valued, who gets repaid from it, and what closes it.
A bodily injury claim asks the at-fault driver's liability insurance to pay for the injury: medical bills, lost wages, and the pain and limits the injury caused. It runs on records, so prompt and consistent treatment is the foundation. It is usually priced after treatment stabilizes, sent as a demand, and negotiated over several rounds. Policy limits, shared fault, and liens from health insurers or Medicare decide what the injured person actually keeps. The filing deadline runs the whole time.
Collision Bureau is not a law firm and this is not legal or medical advice. It is general information about what happens after a crash. For advice on your situation, talk to an attorney licensed in your state or a treating medical provider.
What a bodily injury claim is
A bodily injury claim is the part of a crash claim that is about the person, not the car. It asks the at-fault driver's insurance to pay for what the injury cost and what it took. The medical bills. The wages lost while healing. And a separate amount for the injury itself, the pain, the limits, the months of life that did not go the way they were supposed to.
It is not the same thing as the property damage claim, even though the two usually start from the same crash, the same report, and sometimes the same adjuster. The property side is about the vehicle and things in it. It moves fast, because the car is parked somewhere and can be looked at. The injury side moves at the pace of the body. It cannot be valued until the injury has declared itself, and the injury does that on its own schedule.
The phrase bodily injury also shows up on insurance paperwork as a type of coverage. Bodily injury liability is the part of a driver's policy that pays other people when that driver injures them. So when you make a bodily injury claim against another driver, you are claiming against their bodily injury liability coverage. Most states require drivers to carry some of it. How much they carry is the number that quietly shapes everything else in the claim.
Most bodily injury claims never become lawsuits. They are handled on paper, through records and letters and phone calls between the injured person or their attorney and an adjuster at the other driver's insurance company. But every one of them is handled in the shadow of a lawsuit that could be filed, before a deadline set by state law. The guide to the statute of limitations after a car crash covers that clock in detail.
Here is the simplest way to hold it. A bodily injury claim is a request for payment backed by proof. The request is the demand. The proof is the medical record, the bills, the wage loss, and the story of the injury told consistently from the first day. The better the proof, the less the request depends on persuasion.
Whose insurance it runs against
In most crashes, the bodily injury claim runs against the at-fault driver's liability insurance. That makes it a third-party claim, which just means you are claiming against someone else's policy, not your own. The insurer owes its duties to its own customer, the driver who caused the crash. It does not owe you the kind of good-faith duties it owes the people who pay it premiums. That is not a criticism. It is the structure, and it explains a lot about how the adjuster behaves. The guide on why the adjuster is not your adjuster goes deeper on that.
Your own policy can enter the picture in several ways. If the at-fault driver had no insurance, your uninsured motorist coverage may stand in for the coverage they did not have. If they had too little, your underinsured motorist coverage may add to what their policy pays. If you live in a no-fault state, your personal injury protection pays the first layer of medical bills and lost wages regardless of fault. Medical payments coverage, in states where it is sold, can pay some medical bills early. Each of these is a first-party claim, a claim against your own insurer under your own contract.
And there can be more than one at-fault policy. The driver's policy is the usual one. If the driver was using someone else's car, the owner's policy may apply too, often first. If the driver was working, an employer's commercial policy may apply. If the driver was driving for a rideshare or delivery app, the platform's coverage may apply depending on the app status at the time of the crash. The guides on borrowed vehicles and rideshare crashes map those layers.
Here is the test. Before thinking about what the claim is worth, list every policy that might pay. The other driver's. The vehicle owner's, if different. An employer's, if the driver was working. Your own, for uninsured, underinsured, personal injury protection, or medical payments coverage. The total available coverage is the ceiling most claims cannot rise above without a lawsuit, so it needs to be known early.
Passengers and claims against the driver you rode with
A passenger has the same kind of bodily injury claim as a driver, and often a cleaner one, because a passenger rarely shares fault for the crash. What a passenger has to work out is whose policy the claim runs against.
If the other driver caused the crash, the passenger's claim usually runs against that driver's liability insurance, like anyone else's. If the driver of the car the passenger was riding in caused it, the claim runs against that driver's liability insurance instead. If both drivers share fault, the passenger may have claims against both, and each driver's insurer may pay a share.
The uncomfortable case is a claim against a friend, a coworker, or a family member who was driving. People delay those claims or skip them because they feel like a personal accusation. A claim against a driver's liability insurance is a claim against the coverage the driver bought for exactly this situation, not against their savings, in the ordinary case where the injury is within the limits. That framing matters, because waiting on the claim does not make the deadline wait.
Family claims can raise policy questions. Some policies contain exclusions or limits for claims by members of the driver's own household, and states differ on whether those provisions are enforceable. When the passenger lives with the driver, the policy's wording and the state's law both need to be checked.
And when several passengers were hurt, they may all be claiming against the same per-accident limit. The earlier section on limits explains why that pool can run out, and why the order in which claims are presented does not usually decide who gets paid, though an expired claim drops out entirely.
Here is the test. List every vehicle involved and every driver who might share fault. A passenger's claim can run against each of them, and each one needs its own claim number.
Reading the bodily injury limits
Every liability policy has limits, the most it will pay. For bodily injury, the limits are usually written as two numbers in thousands. A policy shown as 25/50 for bodily injury means up to 25,000 for any one person injured and up to 50,000 total for everyone injured in one crash. A third number often follows for property damage, so a full line might read 25/50/25. Some policies use a single combined limit instead, one number for all injuries and property damage together.
Two things follow from those numbers, and both matter more than people expect. The first is that the per-person limit is a ceiling on what one injured person can collect from that policy, no matter how serious the injury. If the injury is worth more than the limit, the policy alone cannot cover it. The second is that the per-accident limit is shared. If three people were hurt, they may all be claiming against the same per-accident pool, and the pool can run out.
State minimums vary. Each state sets the minimum bodily injury limits drivers must carry, and some of those minimums are low compared with the cost of a serious injury. Many drivers carry only the minimum. That means a crash with a significant injury and a minimum-limits driver can produce a claim that is worth more than the policy, which is exactly the situation underinsured motorist coverage exists for.
Finding out the limits is a practical problem. The injured person does not get to see the other driver's declarations page automatically. Some states require insurers to disclose liability limits on request, sometimes with conditions. In other states, the limits may not be disclosed before a lawsuit. Attorneys commonly ask for limits early, because the answer shapes the whole strategy. The guide on policy limits covers how that request works.
Here is the rule. The limits are not a measure of what a claim is worth. They are a measure of what one policy can pay. When the two numbers are close, or when the injury is clearly bigger than the policy, the claim needs a different plan, usually involving other policies and sometimes the at-fault driver's own assets.
Fault states and no-fault states
Where the crash happened decides how the injury claim starts. Most states use a fault system, sometimes called a tort system. In a fault state, the driver who caused the crash, through their insurer, is responsible for the injuries they caused, and the injured person claims against that driver's bodily injury liability coverage from the start.
About a dozen states use some form of no-fault system. In a no-fault state, each person's own personal injury protection pays the first layer of medical bills and lost wages, regardless of who caused the crash. The point is to pay those early costs quickly without arguing about fault. In exchange, the right to bring a bodily injury claim against the at-fault driver is limited. The injured person can step outside the no-fault system and claim against the other driver only when the injury crosses a threshold set by state law.
Thresholds come in two broad kinds. Some states use a verbal threshold, a description of injuries serious enough to qualify, such as significant disfigurement, permanent injury, or serious impairment of a body function, in the words of that state's statute. Others use a monetary threshold, where medical expenses must exceed a set amount. A few states let drivers choose between full tort and limited tort options when they buy their policy, which changes what claims they can bring later.
This is why the same injury can lead to very different claims in two neighboring states. In a fault state, the claim against the at-fault driver begins immediately. In a no-fault state, it may never begin, if the injury does not meet the threshold, or it may begin months later, once the medical picture shows that it does.
Here is the rule. Know which system the crash state uses before assuming anything about who pays first. The guides on no-fault states, tort states, and PIP coverage cover the definitions, and the state's own insurance department publishes the specific rules.
When fault is shared
Many crashes are not one driver's fault alone. One driver ran a yellow light while the other was speeding. One driver stopped short while the other followed too closely. When both drivers share some fault, the injured person's claim is usually reduced, and in a few places it can be barred entirely. Which happens depends on the state's fault rule.
Most states use some version of comparative negligence. Under pure comparative negligence, the injured person's recovery is reduced by their share of fault, whatever that share is. California and New York are examples. Someone found twenty percent at fault recovers eighty percent of their damages. Someone found seventy percent at fault can still recover thirty percent.
Under modified comparative negligence, the same reduction applies, but only up to a point. In some states, an injured person who is fifty percent or more at fault recovers nothing. In others, the bar is at fifty-one percent. Below the bar, recovery is reduced by the person's share. At or above it, the claim is barred. Florida moved from pure to modified comparative negligence in 2023, which shows how these rules can change.
A handful of jurisdictions still use contributory negligence, the strictest rule. Alabama, Maryland, North Carolina, Virginia, and the District of Columbia are the usual examples. Under that rule, an injured person who contributed to the crash in any way can be barred from recovering at all, subject to narrow exceptions the courts in those places recognize. In those jurisdictions, the fault question is often the whole case.
Fault percentages are not usually set by the police report. The report is evidence, and it matters, but the share of fault in a claim is negotiated between the parties and, if the case goes to trial, decided by a judge or jury. Adjusters assign fault percentages when they evaluate claims, and those percentages are a common place for disagreement. The guide on how fault actually gets decided covers the evidence that moves those numbers.
Here is the test. Ask whether anything you did could be described as contributing to the crash, even slightly. If the answer is yes, the state's fault rule becomes part of the value of the claim, and in a contributory state it becomes part of whether there is a claim at all.
What the claim covers: the parts with a receipt
The damages in a bodily injury claim fall into two broad groups. The first group has receipts. Lawyers call these economic damages, because each one has a number attached that can be documented. They are the foundation of the claim, and they are also the part that most often gets undercounted by people handling their own claims.
Medical expenses come first. Ambulance, emergency room, hospital, imaging, specialists, surgery, physical therapy, chiropractic care where it was part of treatment, prescriptions, medical equipment, and mileage to appointments in many claims. The number that matters is usually the billed amount and what was actually paid, and states differ on which one the claim can be measured by. Itemized bills, not summaries, are the documents that prove these.
Future medical expenses are part of the same category when the injury will need care after the claim settles. A surgeon's opinion that a future procedure is likely, or a therapist's plan for continued treatment, is the kind of evidence that supports them. Without that evidence, future care is very hard to include.
Lost wages are next. Time missed from work because of the injury, appointments, or recovery. For people with regular paychecks, pay stubs and a letter from the employer are the usual proof. For self-employed people, it takes more, often tax returns, invoices, and a record of work turned away. Lost earning capacity is related but different. It is about a reduced ability to earn in the future, which applies to more serious injuries and usually needs expert support.
And then the smaller costs that add up. Household help needed during recovery. Childcare to get to appointments. Out-of-pocket costs for medical supplies. Replacement services, in some states, for things the injured person could no longer do. Each of these needs a receipt or a clear record to count.
Here is the rule. If it cost money because of the injury, write it down and keep the proof the day it happens. Economic damages are the part of the claim that is easiest to prove and easiest to lose by not keeping paper.
Proving lost income when the paycheck is not simple
Lost wages are easy to prove for someone with a salaried job, a steady schedule, and an employer willing to write a letter. They are harder for everyone else, which is a large share of working people. Hourly workers with variable schedules, people who work several jobs, gig workers, commission earners, seasonal workers, and the self-employed all have to build the proof more carefully.
For hourly and variable-schedule work, the usual approach is to show a pattern. Pay records from several months before the crash establish typical earnings, and the time missed after the crash is measured against that pattern. A schedule showing shifts that were assigned and not worked is strong evidence. So is a manager's statement about shifts that would have been offered.
For the self-employed, the proof usually comes from tax returns for prior years, invoices, bank deposits, contracts, and records of work turned down or cancelled because of the injury. Business expenses that continued while income stopped can matter too. The difficulty is that a single year can be unusually good or bad, so several years of records give a fairer picture than one.
Gig and app-based work leaves its own records. Platforms keep earnings histories, trip logs, and activity reports that show what a person typically earned and when they stopped working.
Paid time off is a common question. When an injured person uses vacation or sick days to cover time missed because of the injury, many states treat the value of that used time as a recoverable loss, since the person gave up something of value. The rule varies, so it is worth recording which days were covered by paid leave.
Lost earning capacity is different from lost wages. It is about a lasting reduction in the ability to earn in the future, which applies to more serious injuries. It usually needs a treating provider's opinion about permanent restrictions and sometimes a vocational or economic expert. It is rarely part of a small claim and often the largest part of a serious one.
Here is the rule. Prove the pattern before the crash, then prove the change after it. Whatever kind of work it is, the claim is the difference between the two.
Pain and suffering: the parts without a receipt
The second group of damages has no receipts. Lawyers call these non-economic damages. They cover the physical pain of the injury, the emotional toll, the loss of enjoyment of ordinary life, scarring and disfigurement, and the effects on relationships. They are real losses, and in many claims they are the largest part of the value. They are also the hardest to prove and the most contested.
There is no formula written into law for these damages in most states. Insurers evaluate them using their own methods, which commonly start from the medical picture. The type of injury, the length and intensity of treatment, whether there is a permanent effect, and whether the injury needed surgery or injections all influence how an adjuster views the pain and suffering side. Claims with objective findings on imaging, documented surgery, or permanent restrictions tend to be valued very differently from claims built mostly on subjective complaints.
That is why consistency matters so much. The injured person's own description of the injury shows up in the medical records at every visit. When those descriptions are consistent with each other, with the treatment, and with the person's daily life, the non-economic side of the claim has support. When they are inconsistent, for example when records describe severe pain but social media shows strenuous activity, the non-economic side weakens quickly.
A simple journal helps. Dated entries describing pain levels, sleep, activities missed, work missed, and the ordinary things that became hard. Not a dramatic account. A plain record. It becomes the injured person's own evidence of what the months looked like, and it helps them describe the injury accurately when asked later.
Some states cap non-economic damages in certain kinds of cases, though caps are more common in medical malpractice than in car crash claims. The state's rules apply.
Here is the test. Ask whether someone reading only the medical records and the journal would understand how the injury changed daily life. If yes, the part of the claim without receipts has the next best thing.
The first weeks: notice, claim numbers, and the recorded statement
The claim opens with notice. Usually that means calling the at-fault driver's insurer, giving the basic facts, and getting a claim number. It also usually means notifying your own insurer, because most policies require prompt notice of any accident, and because your own coverages may be needed. Write down every claim number, adjuster name, phone number, and email address in one place.
Early in the claim, the other driver's adjuster will often ask for a recorded statement. That is a recorded phone interview about the crash and the injuries. In most situations, there is no obligation to give a recorded statement to the other driver's insurer. Your own insurer is different, because your policy usually requires cooperation, including statements, for claims under your coverage.
The reason the recorded statement matters is timing. It happens in the first days or weeks, when the injury has not fully declared itself, when the person is shaken and medicated, and before any records exist. Statements made then, such as I am fine, it does not hurt much, or I did not see them coming, can be quoted later. The guide on the recorded statement covers what the call usually asks and why people decline or limit it.
Another early request is a medical records authorization. The adjuster may send a form that would let the insurer collect records directly from providers. Some of those forms are broad and reach records unrelated to the crash, sometimes going back years. A narrower path is for the injured person or their attorney to gather the records and send what is relevant. The trade-off is time and control, and it is worth thinking about before signing.
And early offers. Sometimes an insurer makes an offer in the first weeks, before treatment is complete. An early offer can be tempting when bills are arriving. But a settlement generally ends the claim, including for injuries that turn out to be worse than they looked at first. Accepting early means accepting a value set before anyone knew what the injury was.
Here is the rule for the first weeks. Report the crash, get the numbers, get treatment, and keep the paper. Decisions about statements, authorizations, and offers can wait for a clearer picture, and in most cases they should.
Paying for treatment while the claim is open
The at-fault driver's insurer does not usually pay medical bills as they arrive. In most fault states, it pays once, at the end, when the injury claim settles. That leaves a practical problem in the middle. The bills arrive now. The settlement arrives months or years later. Something has to pay for treatment in between, and the choice affects both the person's care and the claim.
Health insurance is the most common answer. Using it means providers are paid at the plan's negotiated rates, the person pays only their deductible and share, and treatment continues without collection calls. The plan may later claim repayment from the settlement, as covered above, but that repayment is usually based on what the plan actually paid, which is often far less than the billed amount. People sometimes avoid using health insurance because they think the at-fault driver should pay. They will, eventually. Health insurance is how treatment gets paid for in the meantime.
Personal injury protection or medical payments coverage, where available, pays some bills early regardless of fault, up to the coverage limit. In no-fault states, personal injury protection is the required first payer. In fault states, medical payments coverage is optional and often small, but it can cover deductibles and early bills.
A letter of protection is a third option. The provider agrees to treat now and wait for payment from the settlement. It can make care possible for people without health insurance, but providers working this way often bill at full rates, and the full amount comes out of the settlement. The guide on letters of protection covers the trade-offs.
And some people pay out of pocket or on payment plans, which is the hardest path and the one most likely to lead to gaps in treatment because of cost.
Here is the rule. Choose the payment path that keeps treatment going without gaps. Then keep a record of who paid what, because every payer is a line in the settlement math at the end. The guide on who pays the medical bills after a crash goes through each option.
Treatment is the foundation of the claim
The single most important thing an injured person does for a bodily injury claim has nothing to do with the claim. It is getting appropriate medical care and following it. Treatment is what helps the person recover, and the record of that treatment is the main evidence of the injury. The two are the same act seen from two sides.
Timing matters first. A medical visit soon after the crash connects the injury to the crash in the record. A first visit weeks later gives the insurer room to argue that something else caused the injury or that it was minor. People delay for understandable reasons. They feel okay at first. They do not want the bill. They have no time. The guide to the first medical visit after a crash covers why that first visit carries so much weight.
Consistency matters next. Gaps in treatment, weeks or months without care while symptoms continue, are among the most common reasons insurers reduce injury claims. The argument is simple. If it hurt, why did the person stop going? Sometimes the answer is real, such as cost, childcare, a job that would not allow time off, or a provider who was booked out. Those reasons should be documented when they happen, because the gap will be noticed either way. The guide on the treatment gap covers this in detail.
Following the provider's plan matters too. Missed appointments, unfilled prescriptions, and skipped home exercises appear in the records. They can be read as a sign that the injury was not as serious as claimed, or that the person did not try to recover. Insurers and courts generally expect injured people to take reasonable steps to recover, which is sometimes called the duty to mitigate damages.
And the records should describe the crash accurately. When a provider asks what happened, a short, accurate answer that connects the injury to the crash is what belongs in the chart. Every complaint should be mentioned, not only the worst one. A shoulder injury that never appears in the records until month four is very hard to connect to the crash later.
Here is the rule. Treat the injury as if the claim did not exist. Go when it hurts, keep going while it hurts, follow the plan, and tell every provider about every symptom. The records will take care of the rest.
The records the claim runs on
A bodily injury claim is a paper case. Whatever happened to the person, the adjuster will see it through documents. The claim is only as strong as the documents that reach the adjuster's desk, and gathering them is slow, unglamorous work that decides more claims than any argument.
Medical records and medical bills are different documents, and both are needed. The records are the clinical notes: what the person reported, what the provider found, the diagnosis, the treatment, and the plan. The bills are the charges: what each service cost, coded line by line. Records prove the injury. Bills prove the cost. A claim with bills and no records looks like charges without a reason. A claim with records and no bills looks like an injury without a cost.
Itemized bills matter more than summaries. A summary showing a total balance is not enough to evaluate a claim. Itemized bills show each service, the date, and the charge, and they let the adjuster match each charge to a visit in the records. The guide on reading a medical bill after a crash walks through the codes and columns.
Getting the records takes time. Providers often have a records department with its own request form, its own fees, and its own turnaround time, which can stretch to weeks. Hospitals, imaging centers, specialists, and therapy clinics each keep their own records separately. A claim with six providers is six separate requests. Starting those requests early, rather than at the end of treatment, keeps the claim from stalling.
Wage proof is the third pillar. A letter from the employer on letterhead stating the person's position, rate of pay, usual hours, and the dates missed because of the injury is the standard document. Pay stubs from before and after back it up. For self-employed people, tax returns from prior years, invoices, bank deposits, and records of jobs turned down build the same picture.
Then the supporting pieces. The crash report. Photos of the vehicles, the scene, and the visible injuries. Witness names. Receipts for out-of-pocket costs. The journal. Insurance letters. Each one goes into a single organized file, by date.
Here is the test. Could a stranger, given only the file, understand what happened, what it did to the person, what it cost, and how the costs connect to the crash? If yes, the claim is ready to be priced. If not, the gaps show exactly what to request next.
Pre-existing conditions and the aggravation question
Many adults have something in their medical history before a crash. An old back injury. Arthritis in a knee. Prior neck pain. Degenerative changes that show up on almost every imaging study after a certain age. Insurers look for these, because a pre-existing condition gives them a way to argue that the pain or the treatment after the crash was not caused by the crash.
The law in most states takes a fairly consistent view of this. The at-fault driver generally takes the injured person as they find them. If a crash makes an existing condition worse, the aggravation of that condition is part of the injury the crash caused. What the at-fault driver is usually not responsible for is the condition as it was before the crash. The claim is about the difference.
That makes the before picture important. Records from before the crash showing how the condition was doing, whether it was stable, how often it needed care, whether the person was working and active, help establish the baseline. Records after the crash showing a change, new symptoms, new treatment, new limitations, establish the aggravation. The contrast between the two is the evidence.
The worst approach is to hide the history. The insurer will usually find it, through prior claims databases, through records requests, or through the person's own providers. When a prior condition appears in the file after the person said there was none, it damages credibility across the whole claim, not only on the point that was hidden. Being direct about prior conditions with treating providers after the crash gets the records right from the start.
There is an older idea in the law, often called the eggshell plaintiff rule, that captures the principle. A person who is more vulnerable to injury because of a prior condition is still entitled to recover for the harm the crash actually caused them, even if a healthier person would have been hurt less. How courts apply that varies, but the core idea is widely recognized.
Here is the test. Can the records show a before and an after? If the condition was quiet before and active after, that difference is the claim. If the records cannot show the difference, a treating provider's opinion about what changed is often the missing piece.
When to value it: maximum medical improvement
There is a right time to put a number on an injury claim, and it is usually not early. It is the point where the treating providers can say what the injury is going to look like over the long term. That point is often called maximum medical improvement, or MMI. It means the person has recovered as much as treatment is expected to help, either fully or with a lasting effect that is not expected to change much.
Before MMI, nobody knows the full cost of the injury. More treatment may be coming. A surgery may or may not be needed. The person may return to full work or may not. A demand sent before MMI has to guess at those answers, and a settlement reached before MMI generally closes the claim even if the guesses turn out to be wrong.
MMI does not always mean full recovery. Some people reach MMI with a permanent impairment, chronic pain, or a need for future care. In that case, the treating provider's description of the lasting effect, and of any future treatment that is likely, becomes central to the claim. Without it, the future part of the injury is very hard to include.
The tension is with the deadline. MMI can take months for common injuries and much longer for serious ones. The statute of limitations does not wait for MMI. When the deadline gets close before the person reaches MMI, the claim can be protected by filing a lawsuit, and the valuation can continue inside the case. Waiting for MMI is a good reason to delay a demand. It is never a reason to miss a deadline.
The guide on maximum medical improvement covers the term itself, and the guide on how long an injury claim takes covers the timing in more depth.
Here is the rule. Price the claim when the injury has finished telling its story. Watch the filing deadline the whole time, because it does not care whether the story is finished.
Who already paid: health insurance, Medicare, Medicaid, and liens
While the claim is building, someone is usually paying the medical bills. Health insurance. Medicare or Medicaid. Personal injury protection or medical payments coverage. Sometimes a provider who agreed to wait for payment until the claim settles. Many of those payers have a right to be repaid from the injury settlement, and those rights shape what the injured person actually receives.
Health insurance plans commonly include reimbursement or subrogation terms. If the plan paid crash-related bills and the injured person later recovers from the at-fault driver, the plan may claim repayment from that recovery. The strength of that claim depends on the plan and the state. Many state laws limit health insurer recovery in various ways. Self-funded employer plans governed by the federal ERISA law can be treated differently, and often have stronger repayment rights that state limits do not reach.
Medicare has a statutory right to recover conditional payments it made for crash-related care, under the federal Medicare Secondary Payer rules. When Medicare paid, its interest has to be identified and resolved as part of the settlement process. Medicaid programs also have recovery rights under federal and state law, and the share they can recover is subject to rules about which part of a settlement represents medical expenses.
Providers can hold liens too. Some people treat under a letter of protection, an agreement in which the provider waits for payment until the claim resolves, usually in exchange for being paid from the settlement. Some states also give hospitals statutory liens on injury recoveries for emergency care. The guide on letters of protection covers that arrangement.
All of this happens after the insurer agrees to pay, which is why it surprises people. A settlement amount is not the same as the amount the injured person keeps. Repayment claims are often negotiable, and reducing them is a large part of what attorneys do at the end of a case. The guide on subrogation covers how those reimbursement claims work.
Here is the test. Before agreeing to any settlement, list every party that paid a crash-related medical bill, and find out what each one will claim from the recovery. The answer changes what a fair settlement number looks like.
Working with the adjuster in writing
A bodily injury claim is a long conversation with someone whose job is to resolve it for as little as the file allows. That is not hostile. It is the job. The most useful habit for that conversation is simple: get the important things in writing.
Phone calls are fine for routine questions, and adjusters often prefer them. But anything that matters, a request for documents, an offer, a statement about coverage or fault, a promise about timing, should end up in an email or a letter. After a phone call that covered something important, a short email summarizing what was said, sent the same day, creates a record. If the summary is wrong, the adjuster can correct it. If it is right, it stands.
Keep a claim log. One page or one note with the date of every contact, who it was with, what was asked, what was sent, and what was promised. Adjusters change. Files get transferred. Months pass. A log turns a confusing history into a clear one, and it shows exactly when a request went unanswered.
Send documents in organized packets rather than one at a time, with a cover letter listing what is enclosed. Keep a copy of everything sent and note the date and method. Many disputes later in a claim come down to whether something was received, and the cover letter answers that.
Be accurate and brief. Answer the question asked. Do not guess about medical details, speculate about fault, or describe the injury as better or worse than it is. Statements to the adjuster become part of the file the claim is valued on.
And watch for anything that sounds like an assurance about time. An adjuster saying there is no rush, or that the claim will be handled, does not extend the filing deadline. Only a filed lawsuit or a signed written tolling agreement does. The statute of limitations guide covers that in detail.
Here is the test. If the claim were handed to someone new tomorrow, could they understand its whole history from the paper alone? If yes, the claim is protected against the turnover and memory lapses that slow most claims down.
The demand package
The demand package is the claim, assembled. It is a letter to the insurer, with supporting documents, that explains what happened, why their insured is responsible, what the injury was, what it cost, and what amount would resolve the claim. It is usually sent after maximum medical improvement, once the records and bills are complete.
A strong demand reads like an organized argument, not a stack of paper. It opens with the facts of the crash and the evidence of fault: the crash report, photos, witness statements. It describes the injuries and the treatment in plain language, in order, citing the records. It totals the medical bills, with itemized bills attached. It documents the wage loss. It describes the effect on daily life, drawing on the journal and the records. And it ends with a specific amount and a reasonable deadline for a response.
The amount in the demand is a negotiating position, not a prediction. It is usually higher than the amount the claim eventually settles for, because the insurer will counter, and the demand sets the top of the range. But it should be supportable. A demand that bears no relationship to the records tends to be treated as noise.
When the injury is clearly worth more than the at-fault driver's limits, a demand for the policy limits can carry special weight. In many states, an insurer that unreasonably refuses a demand within limits may expose its own insured to a judgment above the limits, and may face its own liability for that. That is a technical area with specific requirements, and policy-limits demands are usually drafted by attorneys for that reason.
The guides on the demand package and sending a demand letter yourself go deeper on structure and tone.
Here is the test. Read the demand as the adjuster will. Every claim it makes should point to a document in the package. If a sentence cannot be backed by an attachment, it either needs one or should come out.
How the adjuster evaluates the claim
On the other side of the demand, the adjuster is doing a structured job. Knowing what that job looks like takes some of the mystery out of the offers that come back.
The adjuster starts with liability. Is the insured clearly at fault, partly at fault, or arguably not at fault? A claim with disputed fault is valued lower, because the insurer is pricing in the chance of winning that argument. The state's fault rule matters here, because it decides what a share of fault does to the value.
Then the damages. The adjuster reviews the records and the bills. Some insurers use claims-evaluation software that scores injuries based on diagnoses, treatment, and other factors entered from the file. Whatever the tool, it can only work with what the file shows, which is why gaps in treatment, missing records, or inconsistent descriptions tend to lower the number. The adjuster also looks at whether the treatment seems proportionate to the injury described.
Then the risk. Would this case be strong in front of a jury in this county? Is the injured person credible? Is the at-fault driver someone a jury would sympathize with? How do similar cases tend to resolve in that place? These questions shape the range the adjuster has authority to offer.
Insurers also set a reserve on each claim, an internal estimate of what the claim is likely to cost. Reserves are adjusted as the file develops. The adjuster usually has authority to settle within a range, and offers above that range need approval from someone else. That is part of why negotiation can feel slow.
None of this is visible to the injured person, but all of it responds to the same thing: the quality of the file. The guide on the claims adjuster job explains the role in more detail.
Here is the test. Imagine the adjuster has to explain the offer to a supervisor using only the file. Whatever makes that explanation hard to defend at a low number is what the file needs more of.
The records build the claim. The calendar protects it.
One request reaches a participating attorney licensed in your state, plus the tow, repair and rental. It costs you nothing.
Offers, counteroffers, and the policy limit
The first offer after a demand is usually low. That is not a sign the claim is weak or that the adjuster is acting in bad faith. It is the opening move in a negotiation where both sides expect to meet somewhere between the demand and the offer. People who expect the first offer to be fair tend to accept too early. People who expect it to be insulting tend to stop engaging. Both reactions cost money.
A useful response to an offer is specific. It says why the offer does not account for something in the file, such as a surgery, a documented permanent restriction, a wage loss the offer ignored, or a fault argument the record does not support. It proposes a new number. And it keeps the tone professional, because the adjuster is a person who has to justify any increase to someone above them, and a clear written reason is the easiest thing to justify.
Negotiation usually takes several rounds. At some point the offers stop moving. That is a decision point. The injured person can accept the last offer, try mediation if both sides agree, or file a lawsuit, which moves the claim into a court process where it usually continues to be negotiated. The decision should be made with the filing deadline in view, never after it.
The policy limit changes the shape of this. If the injury is clearly worth more than the at-fault driver's limits, the negotiation is less about the number and more about whether the insurer will pay the full limit, and whether other coverage, such as the injured person's own underinsured motorist coverage, can add to it. Settling with the at-fault driver's insurer in that situation can require the injured person's own insurer's consent under many underinsured motorist policies, which is a step that should not be skipped.
Here is the rule. Every offer is information about how the insurer sees the file. Respond to it with the parts of the file it ignored. When the offers stop moving, decide what comes next well before the deadline forces the decision.
When your own underinsured coverage takes over
When the at-fault driver's limits are not enough, the claim does not always stop at those limits. Underinsured motorist coverage, if the injured person has it, can pay the difference between what the at-fault policy paid and what the injury is worth, up to the underinsured limit. Uninsured motorist coverage does the same job when the at-fault driver had no insurance at all or could not be identified. The guide on uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage explains both.
An underinsured claim is a first-party claim. The injured person is now claiming against their own insurer, under their own contract. That changes the relationship. The insurer owes its own customer duties of good faith in handling the claim, which it does not owe a third-party claimant. It also means the policy's conditions apply: prompt notice, cooperation, sometimes an exam, sometimes a sworn statement.
The most important condition is often about settlement. Many underinsured policies require the injured person to notify their own insurer before settling with the at-fault driver for the limits, and to give the insurer a chance to consent or to pay the at-fault limits itself so that it keeps the right to pursue the at-fault driver. Settling and signing a release without following that process can, under many policies and in many states, put the underinsured claim at risk.
How underinsured coverage is calculated also varies. In some states, the underinsured limit sits on top of whatever the at-fault driver paid. In others, the at-fault payment is subtracted from the underinsured limit. Whether multiple vehicles' coverages can be combined, sometimes called stacking, depends on the state and the policy. And some policies send disputes over the value of an underinsured claim to arbitration rather than court.
Here is the rule. When the injury is bigger than the at-fault policy, read your own declarations page before signing anything with the other driver's insurer. The underinsured coverage may be the largest source of money left, and the steps to protect it come before the release, not after.
Medical exams, surveillance, and social media
Insurers have tools for testing an injury claim, and knowing about them in advance prevents most of the damage they can do.
An independent medical examination is an exam by a doctor chosen and paid by the insurer. The name is misleading, because the doctor is hired by one side. In a third-party claim against the other driver's insurer, there is usually no obligation to attend one before a lawsuit is filed. In a first-party claim under your own policy, such as personal injury protection or uninsured motorist coverage, the policy commonly requires attendance at a reasonable exam. In a lawsuit, court rules generally allow the defense to request a medical exam. The guide on independent medical examinations covers what to expect.
Surveillance happens in some claims, more often in larger ones. An investigator may record the injured person in public places, carrying groceries, playing with children, working in the yard. The video is used to argue that the injury is less serious than claimed. The answer to surveillance is not to hide. It is to make sure the descriptions in the records match real life. A person who says they can lift light things but not heavy ones, and is filmed lifting light things, has not been caught at anything.
Social media is surveillance the injured person does to themselves. Public posts, photos, check-ins, and comments can all be reviewed. A photo from a wedding, a hike, or a gym can be used out of context to undercut a pain claim, even when the person paid for that day with three days of pain afterward. Many people choose to stop posting about their activities and their crash while a claim is open, and to review their privacy settings. Deleting posts after a claim begins can raise its own problems, so changing what is posted going forward is the cleaner approach.
Records authorizations are the quietest tool. A broad authorization signed early can let the insurer collect years of unrelated medical history. That history is then searched for pre-existing conditions. A narrower approach limits records to the relevant providers and the relevant time period.
Here is the test. Ask whether any of these tools would find something that contradicts the records. If the answer is no, they find nothing. The only defense that works is a consistent account, told the same way in the records, in the journal, and in daily life.
The mistakes that shrink a claim
Most bodily injury claims are not lost in dramatic ways. They shrink, a little at a time, through ordinary mistakes made during a hard few months. Knowing the common ones is most of the protection.
Delaying the first medical visit is the first. It breaks the link between the crash and the injury in the records, and it is the easiest argument an insurer has.
Gaps in treatment are the second. Weeks without care while symptoms continue look like recovery to an adjuster, whatever the real reason was. If there is a reason, it should be in the record.
Downplaying the injury early is the third. Saying I am fine to an adjuster, a police officer, or a provider in the first days, out of politeness or shock, creates a quote that follows the claim. Accurate is better than brave.
Signing broad documents early is the fourth. Wide records authorizations, releases sent with a property damage check, and early settlement offers all deserve a careful read. A release for the car should not reach the injury.
Not keeping paper is the fifth. Receipts, mileage, missed work, and the small costs that seem too minor to track add up, and they cannot be rebuilt later.
Settling before the injury is known is the sixth. A settlement before maximum medical improvement prices a future nobody can see yet.
Ignoring liens is the seventh. A settlement that looks fair can leave very little once Medicare, a health plan, or providers are repaid, if nobody accounted for them before agreeing to the number.
And letting the deadline pass is the last and largest. Waiting for one more offer, one more record, one more call, while the statute of limitations runs underneath. The guide on nine mistakes after a crash covers the wider list.
One more belongs on the list because it is so common: talking about the claim to the wrong people. Conversations with the at-fault driver, posts in community groups, and messages to coworkers about the crash and the injury can all surface later. Keeping the details of the claim between the injured person, their providers, their insurers, and anyone helping with the claim is the simplest protection.
The release that closes the claim
Every settlement ends with a release. It is the document in which the injured person agrees, in exchange for the settlement payment, to give up the claim against the at-fault driver and usually their insurer. Once signed and paid, a release is very difficult to undo. It is the most important document in the claim after the demand, and it deserves the most careful read.
A release should say who is being released, what claims are being released, and for what amount. Problems tend to come from language that reaches further than the deal. A release that names every person and company in the world, rather than the at-fault driver and their insurer, could in some situations affect claims against other parties. A release that covers all claims, known and unknown, means exactly that, including injuries that worsen later. A release that is silent on liens may leave the injured person responsible for repaying them out of their share.
Releases also commonly include terms beyond the release itself. Confidentiality clauses. Promises by the injured person to satisfy any liens out of the settlement and to protect the insurer from lien claims. Statements that the payment is not an admission of fault. Provisions about Medicare, when Medicare is involved. Each one should be understood before signing.
The order matters too. In claims with underinsured motorist coverage, signing a release with the at-fault driver before following the underinsured policy's consent rules can affect that coverage. In claims involving a minor, a court may need to approve the settlement before the release is valid.
The guide on the release of all claims document walks through a typical release section by section.
Here is the test. Read every sentence of the release and ask what it gives up. If any sentence gives up more than the claim being settled, it needs to be changed before signing, not explained after.
Taxes on an injury settlement, generally
People are often surprised to learn that compensation for a physical injury is generally not taxable income under federal law. Section 104(a)(2) of the Internal Revenue Code excludes from income damages received on account of personal physical injuries or physical sickness. That exclusion generally covers the medical expense portion, the pain and suffering portion, and lost wages that are part of a physical injury recovery.
There are exceptions worth knowing about. Punitive damages are generally taxable, even in a physical injury case. Interest added to a judgment or a settlement is generally taxable. If the injured person deducted medical expenses on an earlier tax return and then recovers those same expenses in the settlement, that recovered amount may need to be reported. Damages for emotional distress that are not connected to a physical injury are treated differently from damages that flow from one.
State tax rules can differ from federal rules, and the way a settlement agreement describes the payment can matter. Settlements that include several kinds of damages sometimes allocate the amount between categories in the agreement itself.
This is a general description, not tax advice, and it is not a substitute for asking a tax professional about a specific settlement. It belongs in a guide about injury claims because the tax question affects how people compare offers. A settlement offer is generally not reduced by federal income tax in the way a paycheck would be, which changes how it compares to lost wages.
Structured settlements come up in larger cases. Instead of one payment, part of the settlement is paid over time through an annuity. Structured payments for physical injury generally keep the same federal tax treatment as a lump sum. They are an option, not a requirement, and whether one makes sense is a financial planning question as much as a legal one.
Here is the rule. Before signing, ask a tax professional how the specific settlement will be treated, particularly if it includes interest, punitive damages, or reimbursement of expenses that were deducted before.
When the claim becomes a lawsuit
Sometimes the claim cannot be resolved on paper. The insurer disputes fault, the offers stop at a number that does not cover the injury, or the filing deadline arrives before the claim is ready to settle. Then the claim becomes a lawsuit. That sounds dramatic, and mostly it is not. A lawsuit is the same negotiation with a court schedule attached and stronger tools for both sides.
The case starts when a complaint is filed in court and served on the defendant. The defendant's insurer usually hires a lawyer to defend the case. The court sets a schedule. Then comes discovery, the exchange of information under court rules: written questions answered under oath, requests for documents, and depositions, which are recorded interviews under oath. The defense may request a medical exam. Both sides may hire experts.
Many courts require or encourage mediation before trial. A mediator is a neutral person who helps the two sides try to reach a settlement. Mediation resolves a large share of cases. The guides on mediation, depositions, and discovery describe each step.
Most filed injury cases settle before trial. Trials are expensive and uncertain for both sides, and the information exchanged in discovery usually narrows the gap between what each side thinks the case is worth. A filed case also takes longer than a claim resolved on paper, often by many months.
Handling a lawsuit without an attorney is possible in principle, and very difficult in practice. Court rules are strict, deadlines inside the case are frequent, and the defense will be represented by a lawyer whose job is defending injury cases.
Here is the rule. A lawsuit is a tool for protecting and resolving the claim, not a sign that something went wrong. It is the natural next step when the paper process has gone as far as it can, or when the deadline arrives first.
How long it usually takes
The honest answer to how long a bodily injury claim takes is that it takes as long as the injury, plus the time to document it, plus the time to negotiate it. That can be a few months for a minor injury that resolves quickly, and well over a year for an injury that needs surgery or leaves a lasting effect. A filed lawsuit usually adds many more months.
The biggest single factor is treatment. A claim usually should not be priced before maximum medical improvement, and that point arrives when it arrives. The second factor is records. Gathering complete records and itemized bills from every provider can take weeks or months on its own. The third is the insurer's review, which commonly takes weeks after a complete demand. The fourth is negotiation, which takes as many rounds as it takes.
There are ways to keep a claim from taking longer than it has to. Requesting records as treatment goes, not all at the end. Keeping the file organized as it grows. Sending a complete demand rather than a partial one that invites follow-up requests. Responding to offers promptly with specific reasons. Each of those removes weeks.
And there are things that should never be rushed. Treatment, and the decision to settle. The guide on how long an injury claim takes breaks the timeline down stage by stage, and the guide to the complete timeline after a crash shows where the injury claim sits among everything else.
There is one more variable worth naming: the injured person's own availability. Claims stall when letters go unanswered, records requests sit unsigned, and calls are returned weeks later. During a hard recovery that is understandable. It is also one of the reasons people hand the claim to someone else to manage, so the paperwork keeps moving while they focus on getting better.
Here is the rule. Speed up the paperwork. Never speed up the medicine. And measure everything against the filing deadline, which is the one date in the timeline that does not move.
Handling it yourself or with an attorney
Many people handle small bodily injury claims themselves, and some do it well. The claims that work best on your own tend to share a profile: fault is clear, the injury healed fully and fairly quickly, the medical bills are modest, there are no complicated liens, and the at-fault driver's limits are comfortably above the value of the claim. The guide on settling yourself versus hiring an attorney goes through that profile in detail.
The claims that tend to need an attorney share a different profile. Fault is disputed or shared. The injury needed surgery, left a lasting effect, or required long treatment. Medicare, Medicaid, or a self-funded health plan paid bills. The injury may be worth more than the at-fault driver's limits. A government vehicle or a commercial vehicle is involved. Someone died. Or the filing deadline is getting close.
Attorneys who handle crash injury claims usually work on a contingency fee, a percentage of the recovery set in a written fee agreement, with no fee if there is no recovery. The first consultation is usually free. The guide on what a collision attorney costs covers how fees and case costs are typically structured, and the guide on what happens when you talk to a collision attorney covers the first meeting.
The comparison that matters is the net. An attorney's fee comes out of the recovery, but attorneys also commonly negotiate liens down, find additional coverage, and resolve claims that would not settle well on paper. Whether that produces a better net depends on the claim. A free consultation is the way to find out before deciding.
Collision Bureau routes requests to participating attorneys licensed in your state. The same request can cover the tow, the repair, the rental, and the rest of the aftermath, and it costs you nothing. If you want an attorney to look at a bodily injury claim, you can start a request or read how the legal lane works.
Here is the test. If two or more items from the second profile apply, talk to an attorney licensed in the state before sending a demand or accepting an offer. The conversation costs nothing, and the decisions it informs are hard to reverse.
Have the claim looked at before the decisions get hard to undo.
One request, free to you. We route it to participating providers in your state and you decide what happens next.
Questions people actually ask
01What is a bodily injury claim after a car accident?
It is a claim against the at-fault driver's liability insurance for the injury itself: medical bills, lost wages, and compensation for pain and the effect on daily life. It is separate from the property damage claim for the vehicle.
02How much is my bodily injury claim worth?
It depends on the injury, the treatment, the records, the share of fault, and the available insurance limits. There is no fixed formula. Claims are usually best valued after treatment reaches maximum medical improvement.
03Should I give a recorded statement to the other driver's insurer?
In most situations there is no obligation to give one to the other driver's insurer. Your own insurer is different, since your policy usually requires cooperation. Many people wait until the injury is clearer, or talk to an attorney first.
04When should I send a demand letter?
Usually after maximum medical improvement, once records and itemized bills from every provider are gathered. Send it with enough time before the filing deadline to negotiate and still file if needed.
05What if the at-fault driver has low insurance limits?
The per-person limit caps what that policy pays one injured person. Your own underinsured motorist coverage may add to it. Many policies require your insurer's consent before you settle with the at-fault driver.
06Does my health insurance get paid back from my settlement?
Often, yes. Health plans, Medicare, and Medicaid commonly have repayment rights for crash-related bills. The amount depends on the plan type and state law, and these claims are often negotiable before the settlement is finalized.
07Is a bodily injury settlement taxable?
Compensation for a physical injury is generally not taxable under federal law, section 104(a)(2) of the Internal Revenue Code. Punitive damages and interest generally are. Ask a tax professional about a specific settlement.
08What if I was partly at fault?
Most states reduce recovery by your share of fault. Some bar recovery at 50 or 51 percent. Alabama, Maryland, North Carolina, Virginia, and DC can bar recovery for any fault.
09How long does a bodily injury claim take?
As long as the treatment, plus time to gather records and negotiate. Minor injuries can resolve in months. Serious injuries often take more than a year, and a lawsuit adds many months.
10Do I need an attorney for a bodily injury claim?
Not always. Small claims with clear fault and full recovery are often handled alone. Disputed fault, surgery, liens, low limits, or a close deadline are strong reasons for a free consultation first.